Penn State’s Jewish studies program is facing criticism over a lecture titled “Do We Need to Decolonize Holocaust Museums?” — but new details emerging about the presentation suggest its focus was on the ethical treatment and ownership of Holocaust-era artifacts, rather than a broader critique of Holocaust museums.
The lecture, held Tuesday, was part of a speaker series hosted by the university’s Jewish studies program and featured Erica Lehrer, a history professor at Concordia University in Montreal. Lehrer, who is the daughter of a Holocaust survivor, was a fellow at the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum for four months in 2024, a museum spokesperson told Jewish Insider.
The event description raised questions about why “museums of mass violence — Holocaust museums, paradigmatic among them — have been largely exempt from decolonial critiques,” arguing that such institutions are not free from “entanglements with state power” or inherited museum practices that carry their own “biases, exclusions, and silences.”
The use of the term “decolonization” in discussions of Jewish history and Israel has drawn scrutiny from Jewish organizations and scholars, who argue that the framework has been used by critics of Israel to characterize Zionism as a colonial movement and Israel’s founding as settler colonialism. According to the Anti-Defamation League, the charge “that Israel’s existence represents colonialism is to erase the historic Jewish connection to the land of Israel.”
But the lecture’s focus, as described by the university in a statement defending the presentation, was the ethics of museum collections and the treatment of artifacts taken from Jewish individuals and communities during the Holocaust.
Penn State said in a statement on Wednesday that “the presence of any speaker on campus in no way constitutes an endorsement by the University of the views being espoused. We understand the concerns regarding the external speaker’s use of the word ‘decolonization’ in the event’s title, and we recognize how hurtful it was to many in our community.”
In its statement, the university quoted Tommaso Milani, director of the Jewish studies program at Penn State, as saying, “The term ‘decolonization’ in the context of museum collections explores the ethical questions concerning artifact collections, whose voices are represented in those collections, and how institutions can address historical injustices related to the acquisition and presentation of their collections.”
“This presentation in particular examined questions regarding how museums care for objects taken from Jewish individuals and communities and the responsibilities institutions have when pieces on display were never returned to survivors or their descendants when their descendants asked for them,” Milani said. “Importantly, neither the lecture nor the discussion diminished the significance of the Holocaust, the experiences of survivors, or the importance of Holocaust museums and memorials.’”
The lecture topic nevertheless drew condemnation from several critics, including the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum.
In a statement to JI, a spokesperson for the USHMM, the United States’ official memorial and museum dedicated to the Holocaust, said, “Even suggesting that Holocaust museums need to be ‘decolonized’ is deeply offensive to survivors and the memory of the victims of the Holocaust.”
“At a time when the truth of the Holocaust is regularly denied and distorted and antisemitism is at alarming levels, this is especially egregious,” the spokesperson said. “Survivors played a central role in founding many Holocaust museums which responsibly carry out their important work educating the public every day.” The museum did not respond to further requests for comment following the university’s account of the event.
In a statement on X, Sen. Dave McCormick (R-PA) defended academic freedom but argued that it must be accompanied by “academic rigor and the quality of our education system.” He added that he had raised his concerns with Penn State President Neeli Bendapudi.
Miriam Elman, executive director of Academic Engagement Network, an organization of faculty and staff countering antisemitism on campus, told JI that decolonial theory “marginalizes the Jewish experience” and casts elements of Jewish identity, including Zionism, as “inherently suspect and illegitimate.”
Elman said extending the framework to Holocaust museums was “deeply disturbing,” arguing that the institutions were established to preserve Jewish historical memory and document the Nazi effort to annihilate European Jewry. “Decolonial theorizing has no place in advancing this critically important mission,” she said.
Lehrer did not respond to a request for comment from JI.
The Jewish studies program is also slated to host Raz Segal, an Israeli associate professor of Holocaust and genocide studies at Stockton University, in February. Segal drew controversy in 2024 after the University of Minnesota rescinded an offer to appoint him director of its Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies, following scrutiny of his characterization of Israel’s war in Gaza as “a textbook case of genocide.”
Segal has also described Israel as a “settler-colonial” power and written about what he called the “reality of the system of Israeli apartheid.” His proposed appointment prompted the resignations of two members of the center’s advisory board and objections from Jewish community leaders.